It is a strange phenomenon: the human being who sits next to you at a dinner party and never asks one question about you. I had this experience last night. There were other people at the party who did engage in a more balanced exchange with me, but I was unfortunately seated for dinner near three men who must have, as my mother used to say, "been brought up in a barn." I asked them all about themselves, their jobs, families, etc., and these three men, in turn, answered my questions, and we had a conversation that sounded like an interview. One man went on and on about his wonderful job as an environmentalist; he was also a science professor at UC Berkeley. These three men were in their fifties, highly educated, intelligent, nicely dressed in suits and ties, and never asked me one thing about my life during the cheese soufflé appetizer, the onion soup, the heart of palm salad, the coq au vin, the apple tart or chocolate mousse, the tea or coffee or cognac. Not one. I was a little tired from interviewing, so I left the party early. I walked down the street toward Bart and almost got hit by a bus.
On the Bart train, everyone looked exhausted and like they'd been hit by a bus. We did not ask each other about our lives. It was an equitable exchange.
As the train blasted with a screeching whine through the underwater tunnel, I wondered, what is it that makes us so self-centered? I read somewhere that evil is the absence of light. An opaqueness, a state of self-absorption. Like a dirty window, the light can't shine through. I actually felt dirty, sitting at that table with three civilized men, so highly educated and well-groomed, who were blind as proverbial bats, hanging upside down in their cave of shitty manners. They were only looking at themselves through the dark window.
I looked at myself in the dark Bart window. A sad and tired face looked back at me. I closed my eyes and tried to think of something good, something of light. I saw the face of my friend Maureen who is coming to visit Kenneth and me today to celebrate Kenneth's 50th birthday.
And I remembered this poem, a great poem to pull out of your pocket when you're at a party, and you know it's time to disappear. But be careful of buses:
The Art of Disappearing by Naomi Shihab Nye
When they say Don't I know you?
say no.
When they invite you to the party
remember what parties are like
before answering.
Someone telling you in a loud voice
they once wrote a poem.
Greasy sausage balls on a paper plate.
Then reply.
If they say We should get together
say Why?
It's not that you don't love them anymore.
You're trying to remember something
too important to forget.
Trees. The monastery bell at twilight.
Tell them you have a new project.
It will never be finished.
When someone recognizes you in a grocery store
nod briefly and become a cabbage.
When someone you haven't seen in ten years
appears at the door,
don't start singing him all your new songs.
You will never catch up.
Walk around feeling like a leaf.
Know you could tumble any second.
Then decide what to do with your time.
About Susan
Connections
View all »
Causes Susan Browne Supports
Unicef
Amnesty International
Run Together, A Race to Raise Money for Leukemia and Lymphoma Society








Pass The Salt (For My Wounds)
Call me a cynic (it has happened) but I think you are a lucky person NOT to have had a conversation with these men. I believe they would have only found fault.
Hi Dale
Yes, I'm sure you're right. Your reply makes me think of the movie My Dinner with Andre. Andre talks about just completely losing it in the hospital with a doctor who won't engage in any kind of truthful discussion about how his mother is dying. And Andre goes on to describe this dinner party where all people talk about is celebrities, what the famous people are doing...and then he goes to the desert with this crazy monk to try to figure it all out, and the monk just stands on his head or something like that, looking at the inverted stars. Pass the salt!
happy birthday to Kenneth!
About the gentlemen at the party: It could be that they might have Asberger's or don't have enough social skills to know what to do. I'm just guessing because it's a acdemic setting and all.
And I love that poem by Naomi Shilab Nye.
Jennifer
That's very sweet, but no. Those gentlemen were suffering only from paying zero attention to anything but their own needs. They reminded me of people who talk on their cell phone or keep checking their Blackberry or phone for messages while eating dinner with others. The fellows were not all academics. They were simply all equally rude.
Rudeness! Do you think the world is just getting increasingly rude?
Kenneth couldn't believe it, either.
I will tell Kenneth you wished him a happy day.
That was smart of Kenneth...
and you're right, they were rude.
Thank you
Susan, each morning your posts make me alternatively laugh, reflect, or both, and today was no exception.
The last stanza of the poem is killer, and could almost stand alone.
-Max Sindell, Red Room
Hello Max
That's true! The last stanza is a breath-taker.
Tis the season to be rude?
Hi, Susan -
I had a similar experience at a standup buffet dinner party recently...not exactly the same, but reminiscent...
People would ask me a question, and then when I started to answer would either talk OVER the top of me, or simply turn and walk away. Makes one onder why they bother to ask if they don't want to know?
Don't know which is more insulting, asking and then not listening or not asking at all...
Now I remember why I stopped going to dinner parties years ago...it had been so long that I forgot...won't forget again soon, though, that's fer shur...
Hello Gayle
Yes, I know what you mean. Not listening is probably even worse. I think the fast-pace of life causes the lack of social grace or contributes anyway. Listening takes time and attention, a slow walk with the other person.