The publishing industry appears to be at a Gutenberg moment, a time when a new technology is about to radically change the way the printed word is disseminated. The Internet has already made printed newspapers obsolete as a vehicle for disseminating news. Most dailies in the U.S. are on life support. Their hopes of recovery are not good. Yet print journalists are the primary source for most other news media including TV and the Internet. Who will cover events across the globe once newspapers are gone? How will these reporters be compensated? The answers remain unclear.
Book publishers face a similar upheaval. Digital reading devices like Amazon's Kindle will change the way books are bought and read. For those not familiar with Kindle, it is a tablet-sized device that allows you to download e-books from online sources.
For authors, digital reading devices could actually be a boon. Yes, the price of a book may drop considerably. But a lower cover price and the increased buying convenience could actually boost the total sales of books. Television killed general interest weekly magazines like Look, Life and Saturday Evening Post by stealing away ad dollars from mass marketers like P&G and General Foods. At the time, many predicted the demise of printed magazines. Yet, within a decade, more total magazine pages were being printed by special interest publications that targeted readers with interests in sailing, investing, gardening, etc.
However, there is a cloud that could severely darken the sunny landscape for authors in the digital reading era: piracy. Just how vulnerable writers are to e-book piracy is made clear by an article in Tech Crunch: Stealing Books For The Kindle is Trivially Easy http://snipurl.com/dskjv. As it currently stands, anyone with more than marginal tech savvy can copy and distribute e-books. (Some may argue that pirated songs have not destroyed the music industry. But how many authors can command $100 a seat for personal appearances? )
Authors and publishers have three alternatives. First, we can ignore digital reading devices and hope they go away. Second, we can refuse to make our books available in a digital format. Or third, we can embrace digital reading devices but insist they be made more secure. None of these is a sure bet. But I'm going with number three.
Even so, a larger issue lurks in the digital reading era.
The entire publishing industry is in for a radical change when someone can press a button, buy a book and start reading it in seconds. The current infrastructure of the book biz is centered on printing books and putting them on shelves. What will the role of a publisher be in this new paradigm? What will happen to booksellers? As in the case of newspapers, no one really has the answers yet. But I can offer an anecdote that may provide some perspective.
At the beginning of the 20th century, the affluent drove cars and the masses rode horses. By the end of the twentieth century, only the wealthy could afford horses while the rest drove cars. As the 21st century began, the affluent shopped online line while the masses bought in stores. By the end of this century, only the rich will afford the luxury of buying from a human.
In short, the current system of printed books will survive. But if the past is a reliable indicator, it's only a matter of time before most book reading goes digital. The economics are too compelling to resist.
I have faith that good writing will thrive in any technology. But we are experiencing a revolution in the way the printed word is spread. As someone who lived through the Cuba's revolution can attest, revolutions are seldom bloodless.
About Raul
Connections
View all »
Causes Raul Ramos y Sanchez Supports
Chicar Youth Empowerment
Amnesty International
NPR
National Society for Hispanic Professionals









Every morning I go through
Every morning I go through the ritual of opening the front door and going out for the newspaper, then it's coffee and the paper in my favorite recliner. I read all the front section, all the regional section, and the life/living/whatever-it-is-with-the-funnies, and some of the business, but never the sports. Now when I read the regional section with its local announcements and local crime and community budget issues, I wonder where I'll find that info when the regional paper dies? Washington, D.C., I can find on the internet, but uh oh, even my favorite reporters there are primarily print reporters. I don't know how it will all fall out, and especially wonder what will happen to things before a new system is entirely in place. I see the dis-connected falling further and further behind, and entrenched interests getting a real leg up. Worrisome thoughts. Susan
Thank you, Susan
I appreciate hearing from you. My wife and I have reduced our daily newspaper scrip to just the weekends. LIke you, I used to pore over the paper first thing in the morning. Now, as I munch on my cereal, I work my way through the news feeds from the NY Times, Washington Post and LA Times.
With so many news sources available so quickly, the local paper seems like a rehash of old news by the time we get it. Yet the loss of local reporting could be a boon to corrupt local politicians who will no longer be constrained by the eye of the local press.
I wish I had the answer. There is a baby in that bath water.
e-books ushering in an era of penurious fame
Raul, Your reference article, "Stealing Books For The Kindle is Trivially Easy," coupled with the prediction that E-books are the wave of the future makes dreams of writing for profit mere pipe dreams.
Who knows?
Ironically, in the digital age, love of an author's work may jeopardize her ability to earn a living. If the music industry is any guide, the most popular authors will be the most pirated. However, we also have the video game industry as a model. Because of the huge investment in game development, pirating video games is much harder than duplicating music. If the publishing industry insists on protecting its intellectual property, then digital readers could save the industry, not destroy it.
thanks for the thought piece
very perceptive. right now one of my students has a kindle and I've played around with it but i must get one for myself
Glad to hear from you
I appreciate your kind words, Matthew. Your students, tomorrow writers, will navigate a vastly different publishing landscape.
Raul, it might not only be a
Raul, it might not only be a matter of works migrating from print to screen, but also of production in a digital media. You might be interested in this:
http://eliterature.org/publications/
I´m translating Hayles´s book into Portuguese for Global Editora. I´ve just begun, and the first chapter brings a similar discussion as the one you propose in your post.
These are some of the works in their collection:
http://collection.eliterature.org/1/
Fascinating
The pieces in the collection are works of art that could not exist in any other medium, an example of artists creating a wholly new form. It's fascinating to see creative minds at work in a palette that did not exist more than a decade ago.
Thanks for sharing this.
Raul
A Gutenberg Moment ...
Dear Raul, my friend:
You aptly depicted an unfolding reality with heart-breaking and thought-provoking insights. It is equally unsettling to note that:
"Most dailies in the U.S. are on life support. Their hopes of recovery are not good..."
From where I stand, I see things in your perspective too - because I clearly remember that it's been over two years since I last held a newspaper in my hands. I get all news previously got through newspapers online now - even television and radio.
Yet, I recognize that, as you mentioned in your response to Susan above, "there is a baby in that bath water." But could I have already thrown away the bath water with the baby? It's quite a powerful imagery.
With very good wishes:
Ugonna
http://uwachuku.googlepages.com
Your words are very apt
Dear Ugonna,
How aptly you describe the situation in saying you have not held a newspaper in two years. Ironically, more people read the New York Times today than ever before. But most of those readers are online and the paper is having a hard time making a profit.
Some are actually celebrating the collapse of newspapers. In many cases, they are reporters and staffers dismissed in the cutbacks. They are understandably bitter. I feel we will greatly miss daily newspapers if they disappear.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts, mi amigo.
Raul
Internships in the Digital Epoch
Hi Raul,
I am a communication professor overseeing a number of internships this spring and a student referenced the Gutenberg Moment in his reflection paper. He attended a forum entitled "Meet the News Directors" and was very much interested in the content discussed. I have been cautioning for years that the demise of newspapers is apparent and for students to diversify by learning to use social media outlets, open source software and sites, vodcasting and podcasting tools and to think visual when preparing content. An interesting article in Vanity Fair entitled The Inheritance - http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2009/05/new-york-times200905 - discusses some interesting aspects of the newspaper industry and its shrinking audiences. To be competitive in today's digital marketplace is to GET IN THE GAME now! Thanks for your post! - Best Suzanne
Good advice
The advice your offer students seems quite sound to me. Journalism is undergoing a seismic upheaval and the landscape of tomorrow will look nothing like today's. Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts, Suzanne. I look forward to staying touch.
Raul
A Gutenberg Moment
This article was some what shocking to me about the future of the books, and how they will be read in the future. It seems like the authors really only have 3 opinions, and I think you are right about how the books will become digital and the authors will have to embrace the fact that yes everything will change sooner or later. This article was interesting for me to read, I am not really up to date with all the new technologies that are going on today. It opened my eyes up to what is really going on around me in the technology world.