where the writers are
Obama, not all dropouts grow up to be rap stars...

It's not fun to criticize Barack Obama anymore now that everyone's doing it. Even cautionary blog posts used to feel like a wonderfully lonely place, particularly if you live around San Francisco or on HuffPo.

I warned early on about the dangers of over-stimulating the public expectation gland. You can chummy-up the media all you want but even hookers draw lines in the bed sheets when it comes to being over-used and underpaid.

Hypocrisy is often the one unforgivable sin in politics, as opposed to lying, cheating, stealing and indictment. But dashing the exuberant enthusiasm you created around yourself could be way up there on the list of public service felonies.

Forget Glenn Beck and Bill O'Reilly, not that it's possible. Now we even have local novelist and confirmed progressive Anne Lamott writing witty and literary slams on the president. About the only thing left would be a grade-school Vanity Fair tell-all from one of Sasha or Malia's classmates. ("He's NEVER home for dinner! And he wears Versace pajamas!")

The shock value in taking on the new Camelot has been trampled into the dull thud of recognition and repetition from all sides.

So I was ready to move on. But damn if he didn't set me off like a North Carolina fundamentalist preacher rocket with this education speech business.

It's not about peddling socialism, or "using students as junior lobbyists" (Michelle Malkin) or even pushing "President-worship onto 50 million captive schoolchildren" (David Boaz), though there's been plenty of worshiping already going on.

It's this: Barack Obama has revealed himself as an educationist, deeply discriminating against dropouts like, well, me. OK, I'm hardly the best case in point. But what about Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg, who made kajillions off an idea that hasn't taken in a dime of profit? Or Bill Gates, number one once again on the richest person list in his eternal bumper car mogulism competition with Warren Buffet (and Mr. Gates sells real stuff.) Or Woody Allen? Or Richard Avedon (his exhibit is right down the street at SFMoma)? Or Steve Jobs? Or President Andrew Jackson?

"No matter what you want to do with your life," Mr. Obama said, "I guarantee you'll need an education to do it. You can't drop out of school and just drop into a good job. If you quit on school, you're quitting on your country." Oh yeah. Tell that to "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, who dropped out of the University of North Texas. Or maybe that's author Jane Austen, who took a hike in elementary school.

I know there are other great examples, but I don't read very much, and never remember what I do read, so you'll have to do your own Googling on this. There's actually a Web site, but it had too many big words so I quit halfway through.

There was even an effective broadcast ad today showing pre-teen kids in orange prison jumpsuits warning from the penitentiary yard about the perils of a foreshortened education. Hey! I'm not in prison. Yet. I am in the newspaper business, though, which can feel a little grim and confining these days (despite a rare plug in the President's address). But I'm not in prison.

In the meantime, all those White House Harvard smarties can't even concoct a simple speech to kids without stepping in poo. The Bay Bridge guys who undersold their repair timetable could teach the over-educated Obama braniacs something about the value of lowering expectations.

"Find an adult you trust," Mr. Obama said in his appearance this morning. Exactly.

"He's the only one we've got," a citizen was quoted as telling the AP in a story about Obama at eight months in office. But, as John McCain said, he's THAT one.

I agree with Daily Show creator Lizz Winstead, who said on her Twitter yesterday when the advanced text of the battered Obama stay-in-school speech was released: "YOU WON. QUIT GIVING CAMPAIGN SPEECHES AND LEAD."

Keywords:
Comments
5 Comment count
Comment Bubble Tip

My internet company is just as unprofitable as Mark Zuckerberg's

...yet I didn't make your list? You know I dropped out of high school. Also, I'd like to add to the list of high school drop-outs, Richard Branson, the founder of Virgin; Lex Fenwick, the former CEO of Bloomberg, now running Bloomberg Ventures; and Scott Neeson, former president of 20th Century Fox International.

These are not only business and financial success stories, I would add that all are great philanthropists as well--Scott even dropped out of Hollywood entirely to found the Cambodian Children's Fund.

There are several paths to success, whether you're talking about success personally, professionally, financially, spiritually, or artistically. This president succeeded by conforming and by climbing the most competitive, prestigious, establishment-reinforcing ladders there are in a country without royalty. The man went from a penniless broken home to Harvard Law and the White House. I would add, much like Bill Clinton did.

For both men, their education was their path to success—education was their ticket out, because their very identity and self-esteem depended on it, and that focus worked for them. Everyone always thinks that whatever worked for them must be the way.

I don't have a problem with Obama telling kids to stay in school, nor with him telling them that in general, the more education one has the more career success one is likely to have. I have a problem with him conflating school with learning, which are two different things.

I also have a problem with confusing the goal of white-collar career success (the kind that can only, but is not certain to, occur with certain types of degrees on your wall) with "success" as a member of society. I'd like to live in a country where people are considered important and successful "even if" they are a waiter, garbageman, babysitter or whatever they do...if they are good people who contribute to society, I don't have a problem with them wanting to get to work and learning in their own way on their own time.

I am not even going to touch the "you're quitting your country" thing. I am trying really hard not to address that right now because this is the internet and anything I write will live forever. Also, then I would get theoretical and since I am a drop-out, I am not authorized to do that.

Ivory Madison
Founder and CEO, Red Room

Comment Bubble Tip

Wasn't it a group of

Wasn't it a group of highly-educated men from elite universities that drove our economy into the ditch, but not before they grabbed tens of millions--sometimes hundreds of millions--from the corporate coffers for themselves? The hubris, the hubris.

Comment Bubble Tip

Two of...

the smartest people I've ever known --- one, my father, was a high school drop out, yet based on his IQ was giving commands to guys with law degrees and Ph.Ds as a master sergeant in the Army during World War II, and the other is a former professor, and old friend, Nobel Laureate J.M. Coetzee who has two Ph.Ds, one in English, and the other in Math. The point--intelligence can't be measured by education, enhanced by it maybe, but clearly not induced by it.

Walt Whitman, in "Song of Myself," wrote: "I show that size is only development." How, or if, we choose to develop our native intelligence is a matter of personal choice and, as Ivory rightly suggests, in no way reflects whether our value as human beings.

Comment Bubble Tip

I have mixed feelings about

I have mixed feelings about this. Yes, "educationalism" can be pushed too hard. It was in my family, probably for the same reason it was in Obama's. Parents from immigrant backgrounds, grew up in the depression, etc. Education wasn't just a ticket out--it was their religion! Lots of bright, successful people dropped out of high school, of course. (My father-in-law has a story identical to your father's, Jayne.) Still, it's hard to argue with a "stay in school" message, for most kids. And education has to include vocational training, apprentice programs. Working with one's hands is honorable and important, and I doubt that Obama would disagree about that.

Comment Bubble Tip

high/low

This discussion is fascinating, though slightly above my grade level. I am a big believer in working with one's hands.

Ivory, you were at the top of the list but then i realized that using an example someone who writes dark comic book scripts with one hand, runs a business with the other, sings on nightclub stages and is a trivia master would make Bill Gates feel like an underachiever.