where the writers are
Permission

I lost my three children ten years ago after a contentious custody battle. The judge's decision came down two weeks before the World Trade Center crumbled in a pile of smoldering ash. Being a New York State resident, my new husband and I took our children (six of my eight stepchildren) to lower Manhattan in order to witness the devastation to the city's psyche. Union Park, normally a funky enclave located at the perimeter of the West Village, had become a makeshift shanty town for friends and families who had lost a loved one in the devastation. Faces of the missing posted on storefronts were illuminated by shrines of melting candles and scattered bouquets of flowers. We walked through Union Square listening to music and low chatter. And though the devastation was terrific and smells of concrete dust burned our nostrils and eyes, I hurt not for the survivors. I hurt for me. It seems self indulgent now; but at the time, I felt envious that the missing at least had survivors who pined for them. Though my stepchildren, mere babies, fought over the right to hold my hands, I pined for my babies, the ones who seemed to have forgotten me.

 The term "custody" is such a limiting word. While It insinuates possession and control, it doesn't address how love and a mix of emotions continues to hold the mother and child hostage, long after decision-making rights are terminated. As a mom, I had taken many privileges for granted that losing custody had terminated. I could no longer engage in the most trivial yet intimate experiences with my children. I couldn't make them breakfast, except on an occasional weekend. I couldn't pack their school lunches, fight with them over showers and toothbrushing, and I couldn't hear their afterschool tales. Most of all, I could not recapture through telephone calls what living together provided--a physical manifestation of maternal love, a random hug, kiss, a touch on the cheek, or a shared joke.

I know it was painful for my children and being young, it was easier for them to simply pull away. A flurry of phone calls in the beginning wained to weekly and sometimes biweekly calls. Conversations were generic and superficial. "Did you call your grandmother?" "How is school?" The lack of physical togetherness over time stretched and weakened the grip I thought I had over them. I stopped fighting for the right to be involved in their school events. Internet copies of their report cards held little emotional impact. Missed Mother's Day phone calls became an expected casualty of the distance. 

I also pulled away. It was easier to compartmentalize the desires I had to be with my children than to walk around with an open wound. I did a masters program. I did a nonfiction writing program. I focused on personal accomplishments and on the day-to-day successes and trials of my stepchildren.  It was the only way I knew to cope, albeit not the most effective.

When my ex-husband hospitalized our daughter for a bout of depression and ritual cutting, I listened to him recount the tale with detached interest. When my youngest performed in a school play and asked me to drive four hours to see him, it was a perfunctory act to tell him I couldn't come.  Little by little, I had become increasingly detached and emotionally uninvolved in the lives of those I lived and breathed for.

~

 Last week, ten years after losing custody of my children, my eldest son posted photos of his prom on Facebook. I had not seen them. I have a vague recollection of the event, don't remember the name of the girl, and looked at my son with renewed interest. I marveled how much he resembled uncles in my family and how handsome he'd grown to be.

We have a relationship these days. He calls me on a daily basis, and looks up to me (though I find it strange) the way a child sees a superhero. My daughter, the one who was hospitalized five times before I had her committed to residential treatment for bipolar disorder lives with me. And my youngest son, the one whose mind I could read like my own, lives with his father and calls when he remembers. Ten years later, I feel okay but realize the relationship I have with my biological children isn't standard. It's like a peer/mentor relationship. I have no need to control their lives and they come to me without provocation to share the most intimate details. My eldest son talks about his love life, and in the wee hours of the night asks me for my opinion with the female species.

My daughter, now 20, works full time and sees her life with me as a partnership. She contributes to the household, looks up to me, cares for me and tells me how grateful she is that we live together and that our relationship has blossomed from what it was before the custody fight.

And my youngest has all but blocked out the pain during those early years after the custody battle. He doesn't remember details of those early years -- some good; some awful. He just lives in the moment, which is probably a good thing.

And me, I have permission to revisit this loss, but with greater introspection and wisdom. Most of all, I feel as though I have permission to be involved in my children's lives in any capacity they permit. I have permission to heal and I have permission to admit that I'm not a flawed or bad mother just because my relationship with them was defined by "custody."

  

Comments
7 Comment count
Comment Bubble Tip

It's an interesting dance

It's an interesting dance around the pain of breaking apart children's lives. I wonder sometimes what it would have been like to have been the one without custody. I suppose each side has its own set of hardships. I can totally relate to your ability to detach. Sometimes it's essential to retain some semblance of a "normal" life.

Comment Bubble Tip

Life is a dance

Thanks so much for taking the time to read and share your thoughts!

 

Comment Bubble Tip

A heart-breaking tale....

Dear Merle,

What a beautiful piece of writing!

Since the pubication of my first novel, PUPPET CHILD, I became an activist for mothers caught in the nightmare of family court when fighting for custody of their children. We call them "protective mothers," because in many cases they fight against an abuser. There is no indication in your piece that your ex was one, nor that you were found an unfit parent; after all, it seems that you became a mother to your many stepchildren. That said, wrenching children from their primary caregiver is abuse; not continuing to foster the bond between the children and their mother is not in their best interest.

Yet you are not bitter. I have watched the pain somewhat softened when the children return to their mothers on their own as adults. Many times they don't, and the loss is permanent. I am delighted that in your case the relationship worked out at least for two out of the three children.

I would like your permission to post your piece (with links to this RedRoom page and any other you want) for my group of over 300 protective mothers fighting for custody of their children.

Warmest regards,

Talia

Comment Bubble Tip

Separated yet in relation

Peer/Mentor describes well the change in mother/child relationship when they are physically separated but still in a communicating relationship.

Comment Bubble Tip

hello

i don't know what to say, will just say reading it was an experience.

Comment Bubble Tip

Speechless

All these years, when I hear of another mother's experience with the family court system, I am speechless too. Good mother's lose custody; that is the reality. And the worst thing is that judges make their positions in favor of fathers so blatant that abuse or negligence have to stare them in the face before they rule in favor of the mother.

The only path in this tragedy is to learn emotional survival. Eventually, the kids will emerge through childhood, and we want to be there on the other end when they ask questions or when the collateral damage permits us to step in and pick up the pieces.

Thanks for reading!

Comment Bubble Tip

Permission

Merle--

I can't imagine the pain you've experienced, but you wrote about it beautifully to give a glimpse into your life.  I'm so happy to hear that your children are back in your life and that the heartache is behind you.  You now truly have permission to reflect on that time safely, without the heartache it would have caused you to delve into your emotions 10 years ago.

Victoria--