Of course, not all the English are like this.
"Is this all right, my dear, or is it too much?" The hostess looks in earnest.
You stare at the minuscule mound before you, and resist the temptation of lifting your plate to check if there is more food hiding underneath. You refrain from asking if it is served with a magnifying glass.
In England, there is no need to fight off repeated and insistent offers of third and fourth helpings. When the hostess asks if you would like a second helping, her tone is one of intellectual curiosity, rather than encouragement. In fact, all you need to do, is glance at the remaining contents in the serving dish to realise that the cook did not build in the possibility of all the guests having second helpings.
The English pride themselves with abhorring waste. Hence, there is no wild and carefree scooping of food onto guests' plates. The menu is implemented with minute precision. Eight people for dinner, eight cutlets, eight bread rolls, sixteen new potatoes (two each), eight individual trifles (here's hoping one glass doesn't slip off the tray), and four avocados (half each – no need for extravagance).
Ours is the only country in the world where you are asked if you would like "a" biscuit with your tea.
Some say this frugality is a leftover trauma from the privations of the Second World War, but we were not the only European country to suffer from it.
Others would venture that the English have a naturally small appetite. Interestingly, though, the same people who offer you a single, lonely biscuit, will nonchalantly wolf down the entire contents of the tin if you tell them to help themselves, or if you keep proffering the tin. Of course, there always is the possibility that they are too polite to refuse, and are causing themselves great intestinal discomfort just so as not to offend.
In England, food is not an everyday right or legitimate need. It is a luxury. Hence, much fuss is made over the offering and accepting of it.
"Would you like a little bit more?" (note the "little" and "bit")
"Oh... I shouldn't... That's so naughty... Oh, well... All right... You've twisted my arm – just a tiny, tiny bit more... Oh, dear, I'm being greedy..."
It is not a gift of 50% shares in an oil company. It is food. Just take it.
Sometimes, they will invite you over for a meal, only to apologise profusely for either the insufficiency or poor quality of the food.
"Oh, I'm afraid there's only a small piece left..."
Then why didn't you buy more before inviting me?
"I'm afraid it's only cheap and nasty white bread from the supermarket..."
I am more than happy to eat it but since you're clearly so embarrassed by the cheap and nasty white bread from the supermarket, why didn't you buy the crusty multigrain from the Farmers' Market, and save yourself the guilt trip?
I have long been trying to understand the psycho-socio-politico-historical reasons behind the English complex relationship with food. Is it Protestant austerity and shunning of physical pleasures? Is the giving of food linked with emotional openness (or lack thereof)? I am still at a loss. In the meantime, when invited for a meal by a traditional English family, I take the precaution of eating a hearty, guilt-free meal beforehand. This way, I can be as ladylike as a Mammy-admonished Scarlett O'Hara, pick at my food with the delicacy of a blue-tit and, when offered a second helping, reply, "Oh, no – I couldn't possibly" with the sincerity of a full stomach.
Scribe Doll
About Katherine
Connections
View all »








Love this, Katherine! Such
Love this, Katherine! Such austere behaviour. It would never go down too well in this household! Seconds are a must here- an absolute given. The, 'I couldn't possibly' would soon be gobbled up by the next in line! Great scenario though. I wish. m
Thank you, Mary. In my
Thank you, Mary. In my family, my mother and grandmother cooked such vast quantities of food if ever we had guests, that we had to eat the leftovers the next day. It was simple food – but plentiful. I think perhaps Middle Easter, Mediterranean and Celtic people have that in common. I used to be married to a Welsh family (yes, I choose my words carefully – marry a Welshman and take on half of Wales), and they wouldn't let me leave the table until I had eaten the quivalent of lunch, dinner and breakfast. Needless to say, I could eat almost nothing a day after visiting them.
Fabulous!
Fabulous as always dearest Katherine! Your posts make me so, SO happy!
Best,
Jill
Hi, Jill – lovely to see you
Hi, Jill – lovely to see you again! How have you been? Thank you so much for your kind words – it's one of the loveliest compliment I have ever received! :–)
I am always fascinated with
I am always fascinated with the cultural differences between people. I find your post fascinating, and hilarious.
Wouldn't you love to ask a few people why the English are so stingy with their food?
Inquiring minds want to know!
Annette
Yes, I also find cultural
Yes, I also find cultural differences fascinating, and I think you can tell a lot about someone by the way they relate to food (and money).
I would love to ask some of my fellow-English why they're so stingy with food. Unfortunately, those who are hospitable, share my sense of embarrassed amusement. Those who are stingy, I fear to ask, in case of offending them. They would either apologise in that very English way which so skillfully implies it is your fault, or tell you they are acting in your best interest (another English characteristic presently perfected to an art form by the current British Government).
The truth is, the English – in general – often have some difficulty in giving fully. For instance, they'll suggest you bring wine or pudding if they invite you for a meal, rather than leaving it to your initiative. Of course, I am generalising.
Don't get me wrong – I love my country, truly. I just think it's healthy to poke fun at your own country's defects (after all, every nation has some) – and you can't very well make fun of someone else's country. That would be impolite :–)
Thank you for stopping by and commenting.
What - no leftovers!
Oh Katherine, I read this with my mouth hanging open - partly, in fascinated amusement and shock, and partly, to be ready in case a crumb flew by in my direction. Please promise me that if/when you are stateside, you will come for dinner. We absolutely love to think about, plan and shop for, prepare, surround ourselves with succulent aromas and eat scrumptious meals! We are always thinking about dinner while eating breakfast. Some people live to eat, others eat to live.
This was so much fun to read, I was laughing out loud. I do love your strategy of eating a meal before going to a dinner party. I'd be right there with ya!
So happy you enjoyed it, Eva.
So happy you enjoyed it, Eva. I would love to come to dinner if I am ever in your neck of the woods – thank you for your kind invitation! :–)