where the writers are
Arab American Literature and the Iraq war

I'm reading Gregory Orafalea's book of essays Angeleno Days: An Arab American Writer on Family, Place and Politics. Orafela, born and raised in Los Angeles , has written two histories The Arab Americans:  A History and Messengers of the Lost Battalion. I'm supposed to know something about Los Angeles history and literature because I teach it, but I just discovered Orafela's writing. On the book jacket it says, "With more than 4000,000 Arab Americans, Los Angeles probably surpasses Detroit as the largest contingent in America."  That statement is probably a huge surprise to most Angelenos.

 Angelenos know about our huge Persian community--the largest in the world outside Tehran. Many Persians live on the westside of Los Angeles, particularly in and around Westood. I've had many Persian students--both Muslim and Jews. A Beverly Hills art movie house often plays Persian films to packed audiences. The Persian students at Santa  Monicia College have celeberations of Ei'd, the Persian spring festival. Persians have a high profile in Los Angeles but Arab-Americans do not.

 Orafelea has an excellent chapter "The Arab in the Post-World War II novel" in which he begins by discussing William Saroyan's 1940 autobiographical novel My Name is Aram praising how this Armenian-American writer created real Arab characters in his coming-of-age story in Fresno in the 1920s and 1930s. Orafelea also praises William Durrel's Alexandria Quartet calling it a masterpiece that captures the beauty of Alexandria. Next he criticizes a whole bunch of U.S. novels that stereotype Arabs including Leon Uris's potboiler about Israel Exodus; spy writer Eric Ambler's The Levantine, James Michener's adventure story about Masada The Source, Saul Bellow's Humboldt's Gift etc. Orafelea praises Joan Didion's intelligent perceptions about the Middle East but asks, "are there no American novelists besides Didion since World War iI who have avoided stereotyping by trying to evoke a broader, deeper view of the Middle East and the Arabs..."  He comes up with a short list: Mona Simpson novel the Lost Father,  Diana Abu-Jabar's novel Arabian Jazz, and Arab-American Vance Bourjaily's fouth novel Confessions of a Spent Youth.

 Orafelea says since 9/11/01 a new group of fine Arab-American novelists have appeared: "Laila Lalami, Moroccoan american; Mohja Kahf, a Syrian American; Alicia Erian, a Lebanese American; Laila Halaby, a Palestinian American; and  the 2007 winner of the first ever Arab American Book Award for the Novel, Libryan American Hisham Matar." Orafalea goes on to have a fine discussion of these novels as well as a assesment of Updike's novel The Terrorist both praising and criticizing.

I find this all fascinating because since 2001 I have been writing a manuscript of poems The War Years about the Iraq/Afghanistan wars, and have actively looked for novels or poetry about these wars but found very little by Americans. British write more novels about the Afghan wars--two I've reviewed on this blog (Nadeem Aslam and James Meek). Before the Iraq War started, Sam Hamill and other U.S. poets put up a poets against the war website and there were thousands of anti-war poems by American poets on this website.Leading U.S. poets refused to go to Laura Bush's poetry conference at the White House in protest of the Iraq War.  Also U.S. poets across the country had anti-war readings; American poets en masse seemed to be saying "no" to the Iraq War. Also right before the Iraq War began, theater groups across the country did anti-war plays--I went to two. I bought Hamill's anthology of anti-Iraq war poems Poets Against the War edited by Sam Hamill (Thunder's Mouth/Nation Press,  2003).

After the war stated in the United States there were a few more anti-war poetry readings and then all this activity stopped. I kept on plugging away at my manuscript but felt all alone. Oh well. The Iraq war went on and on and on and is still going on and on. U.S. writers seem on the whole to ignore it as a topic for a rare exception. Orafalea has essays on many topics including a couple on the Iraq war--he seems one of the few still writing about it. I find it all perplexing why U.S. poets, novelists, and essayists did this huge burst of anti-war poems, readings, Poets Against the War anthology and then the poets quit. Why?

 

Comments
6 Comment count
Comment Bubble Tip

I had no idea the number of

I had no idea the number of Arab Americans in Los Angeles exceeds that of Detroit.

Comment Bubble Tip

Arab-Americans in Los Angeles

I didn't know either that the Arab-American community in Los Angeles was so large. The only thing I knew was that there's a large mosque in Culver City and another mosque on Vermont Avenue just east of downtown Los Angeles. I'm learning a lot from reading Gregory Orfalea's bookl.

Julia

Comment Bubble Tip

Has urgency turned to despair?

At first it seemed speaking out in every way possible would cause a change in the u.s. policy now perhaps people are finding it hard to find the words or despairing or trying to keep a roof over their heads, i don't know. Do think people are unable to find venues or are afraid to speak out?
It's strange that in the country whose government initiated the war against Arabs, even to punishing legal immigrants,etc. within the country, it's strange that the dialogue has faded away.
In Greece the poets and essayists still are finding voice in newspapers and other print sources about the war. i don't know about novelists but i'll try to notice at the bookstore next time.
my theory is that the dialogue is continuing in countries of Europe (i don't know about northern europe so much as southern and central Europe) and the Middle East because the results of the conflict are a part of everyday life. The problem of immigration/migration/refugees alone is apparent. Also the journalism is quite good so there are news programs, documentaries and discussions of Iraq if one chooses to follow the news. I don’t think that is the case with the media in North America.
May I suggest a couple of authors for background? I'm reading "Drifting Cities" by Stratis Tsirkas translated by Kay Cicellis. It's a trilogy, the 1rst book in Jeruselum, then Cairo and Alexandria. It's really magnificent. English doesn't have the breadth of vocabulary as does Greece but you wouldn't notice it from this lovely translation. The back cover says the author combines "the exotic brilliance of detail reminiscent of Durrell's Alexandria novels with the sweep and historical passion of Malraux." But this isn't written from the view of the empire or great powers; it's the view of the insurgents. the Greeks fighting to win their country from facists and royalists.
The other is the Cities of Salt trilogy by Abdelrahman Munif. From the viewpoint of a Bedouin community and it’s reaction to having a totally different culture bully their way in to their desert and harbors to take away the oil. I’ve gained a lot of insight from these books. also a wonderful read, I especially like the first volume . the setting is a Persian Gulf kingdom in the 1930’s.

Comment Bubble Tip

Vicki, Thank you for the

Vicki,
Thank you for the comments on Greek discussions of the Iraq war and the two authors you remember who I will look up.

You are right about the silence about the war in North American medias. The corporate newspapers only cover deaths of GI's and battles. Big newspapers are dieing. There's a a lot of moaning and groaning in the remaining press about newspapers dieing but almost nobody ssyas they lied and lied and lied about the Iraq War so perhaps a big minority or even a majority don't trust the big newspapers. Alternative websites discuss torture a lot right now and a rare op ed piece on why we should pull out sooner than Obama says so (see George McGovern's piece on Counterpunch online today).

Most people go on as if this country isn't in a war (actually wars). Oh, there's an occasional documentary film or play but that's rare. There's a small anti=war movement that holds annual anti-marches in Los Angeles in March to commemorate the beginning of the Iraq War. I'm in a small minority obsessed with the war.

Comment Bubble Tip

Wars, is right and u.s. military in Africa, too!

I'm obsessed with the war, too. It seems we have to be obsessed with it since so few are paying attention. And it's U.S. paid taxes that are being used!

For american documentaries on the wars and other issues i go to www.freedocumentaries.org. it's good because there are so few chances for people to see the documentaries in their own neighborhoods.

An excellent Greek investigative news program is titled "Exandas" it wins awards all over the world. their documentaries can be found on DVD with English subtitles at www.SmallPlanet.gr/en (for the english web page).

let me know what you think!

Comment Bubble Tip

books.

"...have actively looked for novels or poetry about these wars but found very little by Americans."

I've written a well-received novel about how leaving to fight war in Iraq affects those the soldiers leave behind (Homefront) and which also touches on the awkward politics of the war, the many points of view about that particular war, and also our country's tendency to latch onto fear of others (anyone who looks remotely Middle Eastern) as a result of the two conflicts. This may or may not be what you're looking for, but if you search on Amazon.com you're likely to find others that deal more directly with these wars.