where the writers are
Why I Defend Roman Polanski

Okay, so here we go.... I swore I'd never write about this, and haven't in the nearly 40 years since it happened, but since there's been so much attention focused on a similar crime committed more than 30 years ago by Roman Polanski, I thought it might be helpful to hear from someone who knows firsthand the difference between statutory rape, and rape as conversion of genitalia into lethal weapons.

In the fall of 1972, when I was in my first year of graduate school, I lived in Greenwich Village on LaGuardia Place. One evening, I went with a few friends to an bar on the upper west side of Manhattan. It was quite late--after midnight. I had a few drinks which, given my petite size, readily went to my head.

The waiter was a tall, slender fellow maybe five or six years older than I--in his late twenties. He was an attractive fellow, had auburn hair, and pronounced cheekbones. I recall flirting with him, and giving him my phone number.

Meanwhile, the radio station where I had a show for two years, an FM station in Buffalo, WBFO-FM, I think, anyway, I finally convinced the station to send me a tape of one of the shows I did on William Blake. It was the one where I read from "A Vision of the Last Judgment."

Concidentally, the tape arrived a few days before my waiter friend calls. We chat on the phone for a few minutes, and he invites me over. I tell him that I'd prefer to meet him in a public place, but then recall the tape---"Oh, wait," I say, "do you have a tape recorder? There's a tape I'd like to hear." Yes, yes... he assures me, he does.

He lives only about half a mile from me in Little Italy, as I recall--maybe Mulberry Street. In any case, he suggests coming over during the afternoon before he leaves for work. I tell him I need to check something out first--hang up, and think about it. I know where the dude works, I think, I know where he lives, it's broad daylight, and I have too much information on him. He'll never do anything to me, so I call him back and arrange to come over the next day.

When I get there, he was fine. We sit and chat in the livingroom. I ask him where the tape recorder is----"in the bedroom," he says. I laugh. Okay, I tell him, bring it the hell out here. "I can't," he says, "it's part of a console. Oh, come on," he adds, "anything I can do to you in there, I can do to you right here." Makes perfect sense, so I go in the bedroom, sit down on the bed.

He puts the tape of me reading "Vision of the Last Judgment" by Willliam Blake on, then comes and sits down on the bed. He starts kissing me, and fondling me. I say "Look, I'm not into playing games. I don't want to do this--I came here to listen to the tape. I thought that was understood," so he pushes me down forcefully, and starts unzipping my jeans. "hey," I said "I said stop, I mean stop."

He ingores me, and out of somewhere comes this insane and idiotic statement: "You can't rape me, I'm an existentialist." By this time, he has my pants off. He stops--sits back, and says: "What the fuck does that mean?"

I said, sheepishly, "It means that I have control of my vaginal muscles" demonstrating, with pride, my knowledge of what a sphincter muscle is, and how it's used....

"Okay," he says, then turns me over on my stomach, and pounds me---anally. I remember screaming, a bit, but mostly kicking him with the back of my feet and all my might.

"Hey," I say, "if you'd only slow down, I might enjoy this."

"You're not supposed to enjoy this," he says, so I take a deep breath---now it's time to think, no time for emotions: 1) I'm not a virgin, so he didn't take my virginity, and 2) I'm being forcibly raped--lord knows what the guy has in mind for me, and I don't want to find out as I lay there being sodomized while listening to a recording of myself reading from William Blake's "Vision of the Last Judgment." It was all terribly surreal, but I wouldn't allow myself to go there, but instead focused on two things: 1) what am I going to do to get out of there alive, and 2). What can I say to make him stop? I told him I was going to defecate. He said "It just feels that way." I say "No, trust me, I'm going to. Don't say you weren't warned," so he finishes up quickly, and I run to the bathroom.

Suffice it to say that what I saw in the bowl was not feces--it was blood--lots of blood. He tore me up, but there was no time to look as he charged in the bathroom, and into the shower. I had to flush the toilet fast before he saw anything.

He's in the shower, and I say: "Well, it's been fun, but I've gotta run. Got lots to do today."

He quickly takes his hand and holds the door shut. "Where the hell do you think you're going? " he says.

From the window in the shower which emits lots of sunlight, I can see that he has a prominent scar on the right side of his face.

"How did you get the scar?" I ask "From a fight," he says.

"Look," I say calmly as I can, "I'm not a transient. I live half a mile from here, and have friends and family nearby. What happened here is your word against mine. There's no evidence of a crime. If you put one hand on me, you will have committed a crime. If I disappear, it will be noticed. Don't do anyting stupid---I'm not going to the police. Trust me. By the time by the police are finished with me, it'll look like I raped you. Don't do anything stupid, just let me go. You did me a big favor. You may even have saved my life. It'll be a cold day in hell before I go to a stranger's house again."

He gulps hard, and looks at me quizzically: "You're sure you're not going to the police?"

I laugh "Like I said, by the time they get done with me, it'll look like I raped you. Just let me go."

And, he did. I walked up LaGuardia Place a half mile back to my furnished room. I told myself over and over again not to let this horrible act influence my feelings about sex, or men, and that what he did to me had nothing to do with sex, or men, that it was an act of violence that used the sex organs as a weapon. On the walk home, I told myself that a fraction of 1% of men would do that to women. I did not tell my friends, my parents, my teachers, my lovers---no one, not then, and not for at least two decades afterwards. To date, I've told this story only a handful of times.

Still, I felt guilty because I was aroused by his smell. I felt like some kind of freak. I felt deeply ashamed that something like that could happen to me, and didn't talk about it, or tell anyone one for two decades or more.

I lied when I told my assailant that there was no evidence a crime had been committed. I didn't go to the police because, there was no concept of "date rape" then as there is now, and I would have been victimized all over again by scrutiny of my sex life.

Why do I tell the story now because there is a difference between statutory rape, or having sex with an underage girl, and rape---an act of violence that uses genitalia as a weapon. A man who wants to hurt a woman wouldn't anesthesize her by giving her qualudes and booze before the act. The only way I knew, for sure, that it was rape, and not my pushing him a bit over the line was when he said "you're not supposed to enjoy this." Somehow, I don't think Roman Polanski had the same thing in mind which is not to say that what he did wasn't rape---it was statutory rape, and if she said she didn't want it, he should have stopped, but I doubt if she, at any time, was in fear for her life. I was, and it was a valid fear.

To this day, I don't allow myself to think about what might have happened to me if I had cried, and reacted differently, instead of trying to argue my way out of. I know why Polanski's young victim, now a woman approaching fifty, wants the whole thing to go away, but I also know that were she torn apart the way I was, she might feel differently.

What Polanski did was a crime against the state of California, it was a felony, and running merely compounded it, but let's not confuse that with an act of violence against women.

Most of those who call the loudest for Roman Polanski's head have never themselves experienced rape. If they had, they would defer to the wishes of the victim for she is the one who was violated. She wants it to be over. Let it be over.

Comments
9 Comment count
Comment Bubble Tip

I read this. Whew.

The link below leads to a local case. Sensational because it was a physician who sodomized several women. My mother was one of his patients a decade ago (but not attacked by him): http://www.aboms.com/archives/010906.html I wonder if you have nightmares about the incident. I wonder you suffer from PTSD associated with this travesty. I've stayed away from writing more explicitly about my own traumas, and I find myself freezing up in my blogs. I do understand the reason why you write. You don't have to answer any of my questions. Just thinking . . .and acknowledging your outpouring of heart.

Comment Bubble Tip

Good Questions

Heartfelt thanks for your comment, Belle, and I look forward to checking out the link.

This event happened nearly 40 years ago, and I dealt with it immediately by allowing myself to go through the whole cycle of anger, depression, then anger again, until I went through the whole range of emotions. My focus was on survival---the positive, and not on victimization. I believed then, as I do now, that we are complicit in victimization if we allow ourselves to fall into the trap of seeing ourselves as victims.

This was not easy, or impulsive, but took months of listening to, and reading how people eviscerate Polanski unjustly, and lump him in the same category as the creature who did this to me. It's egregious, and terribly unfair to him to do that, and unfair to those who survived incidents like this one to compare what RP did to a crime like this one.

PTSD comes about through denial, and not allowing oneself to go full cycle through the range of emotions needed to get well, and get over an event. (I don't know if one ever really gets over an event like this. What is missing from the story is that I ran into this idiot at the Eighth Street Bookstore only about a mile from where the event occurred, about a year after the incident, on an escalator no less. The joker gives me a big smile, and says hello to me. I looked at him like he was out of his mind, and wished I could have made it back up the escalator fast enough to take him outside and clobber him. I'm sorry I didn't go to the police. He deserved to be in jail--he deserves to be in jail now. Interesting that RP's victim doesn't feel this way...hmmmm....) I think the Judge will take the victim's feelings into consideration when sentencing Polanski. It doesn't do him, or society, any good for him to go to jail.

Comment Bubble Tip

btw, I've heard about the

btw, I've heard about the Bergstrom case.... fascinating... way more stories like these than women who come forward

Comment Bubble Tip

Jayne Lyn--so sorry....

I hope it helps you and perhaps others that you wrote this courageous essay.

Roman Polanski should be prosecuted and put in prison for the terrible thing he did to this child and for his cowardly running to another nation. (I would not like it to happen to him, but in prison I would suspect he would experience what rape feels like.)

His victim should not be victimized again with all this publicity and a trial where she has to speak and relive the horrors of her childhood. She has suffered enough. She should not suffer more.

I see no way out of this dilemma. Anything done is wrong. How this man can live with himself if beyond my imagination.

Comment Bubble Tip

Jayne Lyn-- I appreciate how

Jayne Lyn-- I appreciate how well you have written this deeply honest and powerful piece. Wow. And I agree with you that the victim's feelings should mean something in this case. From what I understand, there was also misconduct on the part of the original judge in the case, who suddenly decided to come down hard on Polanski after offering him a plea bargain. However, from what I have read of the transcript, this was not just statutory rape, sex with an underage person, this was rape, sex against the will of the girl involved. The victim said no several times, and she said she was crying and upset afterwards. At any rate, thank you for courageously writing about your own experience, maybe it will help more women who have undergone similar experiences.

Comment Bubble Tip

Roman Polonski is an abuser.

Hi Jayne.

In my opinion, an abuser needs to deal with the consequences of his actions. What he did against a minor girl was despicable and it's so outrageous.Roman Ponloski is an abuser is he a rapist. How can you defend someone who has sexually abused a young girl? And where is the importance of justice? I think he really got what he deserves and I can say it with pride. What was Roman Polonski thinking? I really disagree with you defending him, it's just my worldview.

Comment Bubble Tip

As Christmas...

fast approaches, it becomes quite clear from the call from Polanski's head, that Christ has left the building.

Comment Bubble Tip

Justice is important

For a person like me who was sexually abused in my childhood, I value the importance of justice because I believe if you don't have justice, you will never have peace and if you don't have peace, you can't heal. Roman Polanski is an evil man and he deserves to be punished and humiliated. He's not above the law because of his status as a celebrity. I was a Christian before and I believed in God as my creator and Jesus and my Lord and Savior, but when I realized that they're not real, I became an Atheist . I took the matters in my own hands to fight for justice. If you want justice, fight for it on our own or with people around you that are supportive. Life is all about decisions and Roman Polanski made his choice and now he reaps what he's sown. I hope he burns in hell.

Comment Bubble Tip

Hell

And I hope hell is large enough to accommodate us all.