where the writers are
By way of...

 clarification on my post on marriage equality:

It's heartening to see the many who took to the streets today to show their outrage against Proposition 8 , a proposition which is a travesty, and an insult to the constitution.

In light of my stubborn insistence on inference, the power of innuendo, and nuance, I never spelled out my position on Prop. 8. I voted "No" on Prop. 8, and feel as strongly about the attempt to rescind the ruling, in June, that interprets the constitution such that same sex marriage is legal. I feel as strongly about revoking that right as I would if Roe v. Wade were overturned.

A post that I wrote a few days ago that appears here, and on The Huffington Post, "On the Fight for Marriage Equality," seems to have drawn the ire of a community that I have always strongly defended, or maybe it drew contempt from the knee jerks among them; nevertheless, I state here, without equivocation, that my post was never intended to insinuate that gay marriage isn't an issue, or trivialize the notion of equal rights for any group who is disenfranchised. When I said that gay marriage is only not the "signature issue" of our times, I did not mean to suggest that it is not an issue.

In the previous piece, my argument was only that there are other elements of the fight for gay equality that deserve as much dedicated attention, such as the need for funding that doesn't have an "abstinence-only" prerequisite attached to it, and access to affordable pharmaceuticals, as well as vocal opposition to the politicizing of science which, frankly, would have saved many more lives than the legalized same sex unions. I, for one, would have enjoyed seeing people show up nationally to voice their outrage at the hate crime killings of Matthew Shepherd, and a 15 year old student, Larry King, in Oxnard, California brutally slain by a classmate last February.

Rep. Barney Frank, and others in Congress, have worked sedulously to pass hate crimes legislation which speaks to the heinousness of these crimes, which are human rights abuses, and which diminish each and every one of us, gay or straight.

It is, in a word, heartbreaking that today's national massive outcry didn't happen before Election Day as it would have kept Prop. 8 from passing in the first place. And, instead of pointing fingers at those who funded Prop. 8 campaign, it might be more productive now to look into why there wasn't a more concerted effort to mobilize a protest against the proposition before people went to the polls on November 4th.

The issues are many; the path of proaction, rather than reaction, is the most effective path. But, hindsight is often twenty-twenty. All we can do now is clean up the mess, not just the one made by those who want to turn back the clock on civil rights, but the one made by a decade of confusing religious orthodoxy with medical practicum.

Efforts to stifle dissent, and diversity of thought, with threats of blacklisting, are equally offensive whether they come from those on the left or those on the radical right.

The thought police of political correctness, in the end, only add to the carnage of ideas, and the demise of satire. When we create a social, political, and artistic environment in which one shudders to think of the level of exorciation Lenny Bruce would be forced to endure, we kind of have to stand back and take a long, hard look at whether the ends justify the means.

This election holds the promise that nuance, and complexity triumphed over good guys and bad guys. For nearly a decade, the intellectual environment has been under attack as much as the natural environment from those incapable of moral complexity. And, indeed, there is nothing more sinister than reducing the world to one dimension.

Ultimately, no one wins when ideology, whether progressive or reactionary, is allowed to prevail over diversity of ideas, and human will.



2 Comment count
Comment Bubble Tip

Prop. 8 before and after

I agree with you that it is tragic that the mobilization is happening now rather than before the passage of 8. I speculate about why in my own blog: http://www.elizabethstark.com (also posted on my Red Room page). I agree with you that in many ways, the gay movement has been coopted by certain touchstone issues that have been chosen by politicians. And yet, and yet, I surely do not want my marriage annulled, and I myself donated and fought before election day . . . and was out again today, happy that our numbers are growing, or growing visible, and sorry that defeat was what mobilized us this time.

Comment Bubble Tip

Thank You

for your comment, Elizabeth.  I most look forward to checking out your blog.

 Even those of us who are heterosexual join you in your struggle for equality which is a righteous struggle, and no less important than the one for civil rights which is etched in my memory.