where the writers are
Can you be in love with two people at the same time?

My girlfriend text me the other day asking me if I thought a person can be in love with two people at the same time.  As you could imagine  the texts were long and too many to count. You ask why didn't you pick up the phone? My friend was training a client, so there was three women involved in the conversation. It was basically, them against me!  I have an opinion, you might not agree with it, but here it is.

I do not believe that a person can be in love with two people at the same time.  Being in love involves passion, romance (in the beginning and hopefully through out the relationship) unconditional love, empathy, forgiveness and an ability to compromise and be a partner with someone in life. 

As humans we don't all have the ability to easily forgive, comprise, or share our life with someone else. Most of us only know what unconditional love is through our children. If  you love your spouse or partner with unconditional love you are very lucky to have found that while walking the earth in flesh and blood. 

When you are in love with someone whenever you see them you get a smile on your face, or when they are gone there is an aching in your body for them that can't be taken away by tylenol or advil.  Only that person can take away the pain inside you with their presence. You can't imagine your life without them. How would you go on? 

Being in love with someone is fierce and dangerous. I say dangerous because a person becomes vulnerable.  As a woman who has not let many people in due to loss in my life, being vulnerable means I am standing at the edge of a cliff with only one toe stopping me from falling over.  I am in love with one man, Mark, I didn't let him in until the age of thirty five, I am now thirty nine.  I have never felt such loyalty and protectiveness towards a man.  Let me tell you, at times my love for him has caused me great anxiety. You ask why?  What if he died? What if he disappointed me?  I would not handle it well. For he has my heart, my mind, my body and my soul in his possession. No one has ever attained the ability to even take one of those important aspects of who I am away from me. I gave them to him with trust. It was not easy for me to take a plunge into the unknown sea.  These are truly unchartered waters for me.  I am making my way, charting my course, but at times, with many storms brewing above and churning inside of me.  There are times where I pull back because I feel way too anxious, and I would rather end something than have my insides ripped out again due to disappoint or death!

How could someone be in love with two people at the same time and go through all of that?  I know, I am not normal. But my God, I can tell you if I would be dead from a heart attack if I was having to feel all those feelings twice over!

I did say I believe it is possible to be in love with one person and love another. I am in love with Mark, but I love my ex-husband. My ex-husband and I share children and had ten years together. How could I not love him?  Being in love is a different experience. It is extraordinary and scary. 

Maybe I am wrong or I maybe I am right.  Love is a funny thing. It can blind you and paralyze you.  Those are two things we can't imagine happening to ourselves in life. But we welcome them when we find love!

My father was in love with my mother. He loved her with all his heart.  The day she died, my father had to go down to the local hospital and ID her. He came home to his three little children, told us your mother will never come home again, she in a place called heaven.  That day my father's heart broke in two and has never been mended. He has never fallen in love again. He cannot say my mother's name, Bonnie, without tears welling up in his eyes. That was thirty six years ago.

When he talks about my mother I stare at him. I watch his eyes and his lips. The love he felt for her was great and filled his soul with joy.  A huge piece of him left him the day she died.  I believe watching him and his pain for years was a part of the reason I never let love in.  I didn't want to go through hell on earth if I lost the one I loved with such intensity. 

I finally let love in because I finally learned what life is about. 

Comments
11 Comment count
Comment Bubble Tip

love

Love is a strong desire, human being always strives for. It is about caring, liking and honoring someone without expecting anything in return. But love can not solve your problems; some times it creates many. And it is also a sad part of it. Love cannot be a remedy for any illness. I don’t believe in ‘love can make a bridge’ theory. True love is capable for only and only one thing and that is “to love”. I don’t think one person can truly love two or more persons at a time, and if situation looks like so, be sure that both the affairs are fake. How can you say two persons at a time that ‘you are my sweet heart?'

                                                                                 jitu

 

 

Comment Bubble Tip

Folk Wisdom

"All's fair in love and war" or is it actually?  A note of reality or cynicism:  Never under-estimate the  human capacity/inclination to be duplicitous/kniving in advancing their own selfish interests.  When I was in the military and college, more than one colleague was quite capable of and apparently comfortable with using  "endearing terms" in more than one relationship.  Some even boasted about their "conquests."  But not all men (or women) are  such scroundrels.

Comment Bubble Tip

Heather, I hear you loud and

Heather, I hear you loud and clear! M

Comment Bubble Tip

i want to kill myself...

its true that one cannot be in love with two people at the same time....but life becomes tough when you are already in love and fell in love again with somebody else...i know i wont be able to explain my feelings..but am struggling right now...every day i fight with my feelings..to decide whom i love the most..i never wanted to betray anyone of them..on one side i have 6 yrs of relationship filled with one sided compromise and on other side i have unconditional love.....oh god its so tough.....

Comment Bubble Tip

I hear you loud and clear

Kimmy,

This recently happened to me after 43 years of marriage.I wasn't looking for it.It just happened.I fell in love with a guy 3000 miles away.I fell in love with his words,his poetry,his sensitiviity.He recently has dropped me like a hotcake.I am still licking my wounds,trying to understand what happened,and what was the purpose of him coming into my life.

Here is a poem I wrote about him:

THROUGH THE LOOKING GLASS,DARKLY

When I was a tiny girl
(after having heard the story
Of Alice through the looking glass)
I wondered what lay behind that glass over the mantel
Too high for me to see
And imagined if I went through it
There would be another parallel world
Where everything was backwards
Terror/serenity
Anger/laughter
Hate/love
Mmisunderstanding/validation
Now I am all grown up
(or so I think)
I have looked behind that glass
And saw a soul looking back at me
Echoing what I thought but had never said
And I crossed over into that parallel world
Expecting it to be like my childhood dreams
Where I would be seen and heard and held
By this other soul
In his arms,warm and safe
Him warm and safe,too
Both givers not used to taking
Losing self in the process of giving
In trying to please the other
So we would be loved.
But as I passed through that glass I heard a cracking all around me
As my heart was opened
The icy numbness melting
Tears flowing freely,faster and faster,unbtil I could not contain them.
Then I stopped,
listening for his invitation
To meld that cracking soul with his own,
But he was gone,
And the glass was cracking all around me.

Comment Bubble Tip

I don't see anything

I don't see anything logically or emotionally that would preclude one from feeling "unconditional" love for more than one person at a time just as one can obviously hate more than one person at a time.  Of course, the whole issue would "turn on" one's definition of the words LOVE and UNCONDITIONAL  Stipulative, "personalized" definitions can make words mean anything we want them to mean.  That issue comes up in ALICE IN WONDERLAND!   Moreover, even if there were some "logical" argument or "definition" barrier, the whole experience of "romantic infatuation" defies all definitional limits, logic, common sense and anything else that normally keeps one grounded in reality.

  Serious scholars in these areas of human behavior would also make a distinction between a more superficial but nevertheless powerful  physical/sexual  "attraction" and a "deeper" emotional commitment of truly VALUING/LOVING  ("warts" and all) another person.  The term "being in love"  is often the former only, as some people discover after the initial "glow" wears off and they realize there wasn't anything deeper in their relationship and/or they weren't ready or mature enough to work on nurturing anything deeper. 

 We also need to remember Wordsworth's wisdom in romantic poetic theory that "we murder to dissect," alerting us that the world of romance and scientific analysis  are as incompatible as oil and water!   [Reminds one of  comedian Groucho Marx's infamous definition of "incompatitble" as a reason for the dissolution of a marital relationship:   "He didn't have any income and she wasn't "patible." ]  Probably sounds a little sexist these days!  Sorry for introducing some sobering realities (possibly cynicism) into this whole highly  "charged" and volatile  area of human experience.

Comment Bubble Tip

One two...

Hi Heather:

It is not love at all if you do not love more than one person.  It's got to be your partner and you...and, love is conditional because there are expectations of passion, romance, emotions to be reciprocated. Even priests and nuns from every faith want that little extra bit from the god they profess to love unconditionally. 

~F

Comment Bubble Tip

Realism

Farzana,

You've provided a healthy dose of realism:  it's  idealistic and "nice" to fantasize about a certain  instinctual, selfless love without conditionality  (maybe a possibility during "pure" moments between mother and child) but, as you say, the reality is reciprocity is essential for love to be experienced mutually in its fullest dimension. 

As noted in my comment above, a major sense in which the word "love" is used, at least from my male perspective,  is simply attraction.  According to what I've read and concluded from my own experience and discussions with others, the "psychology" of male-female attraction may well be different for each sex.  Women, from this perspective, are programmed genetically to seek a mate that will give them security (protection), provide sexual fulfillment, and offer potential (genetically and nurturing abilities) as a father.   Men's genetic programming, in contrast, may have a narrower focus on and goal of simply continuing/perpetuating their individual "gene" lines.  Having this biological nature, many men, in any sexual relationship,  really have to "work on" moving beyond "desire" to anything deeper denoted by the word "love."  When serving their sexual needs, men are prone, in my opinion, to using the word "love" or "in love" rather cavalierly and superficially.  [I know, this view establishes my reputation as a cynic but I'd rather be a cynic than a fake.] 

 

Comment Bubble Tip

Lost love regained

What about two carefree young lovers who separate in an angry moment? When they realize years later what they have lost, they try to reconnect, but it's too late. They cannot find each other. Each marries, she in a loveless arranged marriage, he to a good woman whom he loves with all his heart. Then twenty years after the separation, the young lovers, now middle-aged, meet and the love that they had  lost is rekindled. This good man loves two women. With all his heart.

At least, that's the way I tell the story in my novella, Sakura. See a comment on the book here in Red Room.

Harlan Hague

Comment Bubble Tip

You're a hopeless romantic

You're a hopeless romantic (just kidding)!  As a realist, I would add to your example above, and  "with all his genes," given what we know about the innate sexuality of the TYPICAL  male.  Then again, your male "hero" could be a rare exception to the norm.

Comment Bubble Tip

Puzzled

I fell in love with Siamese twins and everything was going fine until the operation.