where the writers are
"Felicity and Barbara Pym should be mandatory reading..."
Cover of Felicity and Barbara Pym

"Harrison Solow is a writer of experience at least as diverse as that of her principal voice in this unusual, charming and astringent piece of writing which some will read as an epistolary novel (no adjectival form of the term ‘e-mail’ having yet been generated), some as both a practical and philosophical introduction to, and summing-up of, the nature and uses of literature and its discussion – and others as a delightfully readable and comic drama of the generations, of cantankerous yet worldly-wise tutor and idealistic yet impatient young American student trying to set up lines of communication about the (highly) English novelist Barbara Pym -- not to mention the strange pathways that lie between the cradle and the grave, linking even Tunbridge Wells, a West Wales butcher and Hollywood.

Harrison Solow’s creation, Mallory Cooper, while constantly negotiating a constellation of identities that range between the American, the Catholic, the Jewish, the English and the Welsh has, notwithstanding, yet to find the fence on which she might be willing to sit. This is a book of strong opinions, valiant, forthright and elegant, laid out in defiance of yea-sayers, bet-hedgers, academic bureaucrats and bureaucratic academics.  It will infuriate as well as stimulate (as Mallory Cooper, who is not short of self-knowledge, well knows), prompt both wry and outright laughter and stir deeper reflections.

It should be mandatory reading for all undergraduate students of English Literature; no American students of English Literature should be allowed to set foot upon campus without having proved that they have read it (as well as answering a brief catechism on the subject of afternoon tea, high tea, dinner, supper and lunch – and explaining to Mallory Cooper’s satisfaction the significance of ‘dowdiness’ within a British context).  They will be the more likely to obtain a degree if they do.  After all, their tutors will certainly read it.

And if there emerges from all this a valuable reader’s guide to Barbara Pym (and there does), it is as a by-product of what is a fluent testimony and exploration of writing, reading, the significance of value, the rigours of understanding and judgement, and the fact that it is adult to realise that there are no short-cuts to scholarship. For Barbara Pym’s novels also just happen to be the subject of that first term-paper that Felicity the new student must write, a stalking-horse for the whole host of literary, cultural, philosophical and spiritual issues that restlessly inhabit Mallory Cooper (and which – one should stress -- do not specifically demand of the reader any prior knowledge of Pym to appreciate and enjoy).

~Peter Miles Emeritus Fellow of the English Association

From the introduction to Felicity & Barbara Pym

6 Comment count
Comment Bubble Tip

Congratulations on the

Congratulations on the superb review, not only for its praise but the thought and respect that went into the writing of it. deep wishes for much success with the book.

Comment Bubble Tip

Thank you, Bob.

I thought it was extraordinarily generous of Peter Miles to give such attention to this review. It was, in fact submitted to the Welsh Arts Council and I found out last week that the book was awarded a Welsh Book Council grant - this goes to the publisher for promotion beyond the publisher's budget and is given to those books that the Council think best represents literary arts in the country. I'm very grateful to Professor Miles. Thank you for your deep wishes. Chag Sameach Purim. H

Comment Bubble Tip

It sounds as if there is

It sounds as if there is nothing ''dowdy'' about your book Harrison. Congratulations, it must be a marvellous feeling overall. m

Comment Bubble Tip

Diolch i chi, Mary!

Certainly having Peter Miles' endorsement is a marvellous feeling. And there have been many excellent reviews. But of course, these come from people with like minds. I have no doubt that vitriol will be forthcoming when/if the academics theorists read it. But then (with notable exceptions) one hardly wants praise from that quarter! However, right now, pre-publication ignorance and bliss is a delightful (if short-lived) state. Thank you for your kind words. :)

Comment Bubble Tip

Diolch i chi has to be -

Diolch i chi has to be - thank you! Right? m

Comment Bubble Tip


Literally "thanks to you"  (formal) but colloquially, "thank you." And now I am off across the bay to San Francisco, to celebrate Chinese New Year (the tradition of one of my daughters in law), Valentine's Day, and several other assorted holidays/commemorations. Thank you again, Mary. I still have your posts to read - they look intriguing!