I've been asked a fair few times recently if I can explain how to tell the difference between an ordinary Japanese wife or teahouse girl and a Yoshiwara courtesan in Japanese prints... so here goes. One of the first things that most people learn, from reading about Japanese prints, is that Yoshiwara women wore their obi tied at the front, and that does give us our first clue. Were you to rely upon that alone, however, you'd conclude that the woman shown standing in this print by Utamaro on the right (from the series Fûzoku ukiyo hakkei, 'Eight Views of Customs of the Floating World') is a courtesan... and you'd be wrong. She is in fact a widow. Compare the decoration, or rather the lack of it, on her robes in comparison with these ladies below.
This print, by Chôkôsai Eishô, depicts Hanaôgi, Segawa, and Miyahito, who were all courtesans of the Ôgiya brothel. Look at the bold and colourful patterns on their multi-layered robes... no modest merchant's wife or geisha would have dressed in such a flamboyant manner. High-ranking courtesans wore the most expensive and lavish brocade, whereas a respectable woman, whether married or not, would have been required to own a more subdued wardrobe.
And let's not forget the entourage. Many of the full-length images of courtesans include at least one attendant, as these women were rarely without their kamuro (child apprentice) at their side. Take a look at the image below by Chôbunsai Eishi, depicting Hanaôgi walking along with her young kamuro, Yoshino and Tatsuta; one walking before her and the other following behind. Look at the way the little kamuro have their hair dressed.

The clothes of both the courtesan herself and her attendants and the ornate style in which the kamuro's hair is dressed, not to mention the positioning of the figures in a processional manner, set them apart from the ordinary women and children depicted in scenes set outside of the Yoshiwara, such as the one below by Katsukawa Shunchô, which is one sheet from a pentaptych (five-sheet print) depicting calligraphy students chatting away as they walk along on a visit to a shrine.
Look at the modest clothes worn by the women in Shunchô's print, their simple hairstyles, and the relaxed manner in which they walk along engrossed in conversation with the other members of the group.

So now you may be wondering how you're supposed to tell the difference if you're looking at a bust portrait, so you don't have much to work with where clothes are concerned, and there are no kamuro in sight. Well, there's always the hair. A young teahouse waitress, such as the renowned beauty Ohisa of the Takashimaya, would have worn her hair with a modest amount of adornment, and never piled up in the elaborate styles worn by women of the Yoshiwara. Compare this portrait of her by Utamaro, below, with the image that follows it, of the courtesan Hanaôgi by the artist Ichirakutei Eisui... and look at all those hair pins in Hanaôgi's hair.

About Gina
Connections
View all »
Causes Gina Collia-Suzuki Supports
PETA
The World Wildlife Fund
RSPCA
Cancer Research UK








fascinating!
I'm not sure I've absolutely got the distinction -- the calligraphy students all look pretty ornamented to my untrained eyes -- but at least I would know what to look for. Great post! Thanks.
Glad you liked the post,
Glad you liked the post, Evie.
They are rather togged-up aren't they, the kiddies going off to the shrine... they are all wearing their 'Sunday best'. It's often the case with courtesans that the attendants in their entourage are all dressed alike, whereas the calligraphy students are wearing different robes with no attempt at uniformity. I love the calligraphy students print... it's so colourful and lively.
I just assumed (showing how
I just assumed (showing how innocent and naive I am) that the telling feature would be the discussion of price.
Aha, I knew you'd know a bit
Aha, I knew you'd know a bit about the subject!
In the Ye Olde Days, Japanese courtesans didn't talk about money with their clients, or touch the stuff. It was all taken care of by the brothel owners, so that the women could play at being 'lovers' rather than paid prostitutes. Smoke and mirrors and all that.
"Smoke and mirrors" sounds
"Smoke and mirrors" sounds like an opium den(s).
Know a bit about those too
Know a bit about those too do you? I'm too innocent to know what the mirrors would be used for.
They enhance the effect of
They enhance the effect of inferior opium by making you see double. And here I thought everyone knew that.
You'd think I would know
You'd think I would know that wouldn't you, considering all the time I spent with those pirates... but I was locked in a cabin to prevent me getting my hands on the Glen Grant, so my education is sorely lacking.
I'm not sure I appreciate the benefits of seeing double... my mother-in-law might call, and two of her would frighten me half to death.
If two mothers-in-law would
If two mothers-in-law would frighten you half to death, beware the results of four mothers-in-law.
Four? Four? Are you trying
Four? Four? Are you trying to do away with me? I'm in my prime, it would be such a waste. If anyone wants me, I'll be in therapy for the next seven years.
Isn't it a broken mirror
Isn't it a broken mirror which leads to seven years of therapy?
It's either that or the
It's either that or the slightly wonky application of eye-liner and irregular eyebrow pluckings. So I hope you have a spare.
Terrific post, Gina!
I wonder how the manner of wearing the obi front or back got started.
A lot of people these days
A lot of people these days believe that the courtesans began wearing their obi tied at the front for easy access, but that's not the case. Up until the mid seventeenth century, obi were all very thin (about 3 to 4 inches wide) and were tied at the front or side. When the width increased to eight or more inches, and the bows became more and more ornate, it became impractical for the most part to wear the obi tied at the front. Ordinary women began wearing the bow at the back for practical reasons. I don't suppose that courtesans had to consider the practicalities of bending forward to wash clothes, or of walking about for long distances, as they spent their time sitting/lying about and being waited on hand and foot.
There was a courtesan once (I forget her name) who wore an obi so wide that you could just about see her eyes and nose over the top of it... that fashion didn't catch on!