where the writers are
The Small Picture

I was the voyeur. A voyeur with an unwieldy bad camera. After having shot the lakes, the hills, the greens, and posed near all of these, the background to the background, the carrier of memory, the lushness of the Meghalaya village in North East India, where huts are built on stilts, brought home some home-truths. The Khasi tribes are among the poorest, and like many poor people, they have no choice. They do not care about how they are portrayed and they do not care how they are perceived. 

I had tried to strike up a conversation with the woman; for some reason I called her the spider woman, because she was at the loom weaving a cloth that would take weeks, but cost little and brought her little. This was sustenance.

 Since words were inadequate, our communication deadpan, I took a picture. There was no choice of angle. The baby tied to her, back to back with a little hook, was compelling enough. This was one creation she would not let go of. The fabric would be sold. An unknown maker, an unknown buyer, an unknown wearer.

Can I even dare to compare the child to the web she weaves? Will he not grow up and leave, be sold into the large marketplace and labour? The fabric of humanity may look rather pleasant, but we are all being woven by somebody else’s perceptions and needs. 

There is also the mother-child bond. Both are expressionless. In these parts the child is nursed until quite late. A malnourished mother ensures the baby is not hungry. If her frail frame can work at a raw and shaky loom, then why can her breasts not ooze out a little milk?

 There is silence in this picture. One might think it is the silence of the lambs being herded. I see it as the silencing of noise and clutter. This is simplicity. A simplicity that I have complicated with my projected thoughts. It is not that a photograph speaks a thousand words, but that anything that does we make complex by adding to it – or subtracting from it. In fact, the addition is the subtration.

But, then, even as voyeur, I learned a bit – about bonding, about innocence, about fatalism, about living, about life. About the complex simple.

Comments
9 Comment count
Comment Bubble Tip

It's all there

I learned a bit – about bonding, about innocence, about fatalism, about living, about life. About the complex simple.

Yes, Farzana, it's all there in the picture. Much to think about.

Comment Bubble Tip

And yet...

Hello Dolores:

...and yet there is the missing, and missed, moment that escapes us. At least I felt it. What I'd I had watched in sad of clicked?

~F

Comment Bubble Tip

Her back

Farzana,

Addition is subtraction, or the complex simple is all we need to hear it.  Without your words, this photo looks just beautiful although the women's back suggests her concern.

Comment Bubble Tip

Keiko: I believe words and

Keiko:

I believe words and images work best together. The photograph inspired me, but did I think so much about it when I took the picture? I often like to use pictures with my writing because it is a great accompaniment.

~F

Comment Bubble Tip

~ f - complex and simple and

~ f - complex and simple and yet much more than words can portray. There have been times when I have wanted to take photographs of people in this country and they will not allow it believing it to steal the soul. Yes indeed the simple is complex and the complex is simple. mx

Comment Bubble Tip

M: I must be stealing quite a

M:

I must be stealing quite a few souls then. Seriously, there is indeed the thought about infringing privacy and I try and keep that in mind...although in these parts they are so much the backdrop, that they have begun to believe in their insignificance or photo op potential. In some villages, little kids will ask to be photographed because it connects them to a bugger world; a few demand pens or just the opportunity to walk along.

This is probably just simple.

~F

Comment Bubble Tip

~ f, I see exactly what you are saying here. The insignificance

~ f , I see what you are saying here, how sad to think that the photo op wins over because of the insignificance or perceived insignificance. I tried to take a photograph of a farmer out in Connemara and when I focussed my lens at him he lifted a big stick in the air and damned me for my feeble attempt. What you say might sound simple but it is complex and profound as all of your words and blogs. mx

Comment Bubble Tip

Simply complex

M:

The photo-op has its place, but it tends to take over the real...akin to news that is sensationalised, although much less harmful than that widespread virus. 

Significance and insignificance beocme relative to the context and intent. 

Always wonderful to have your understanding, whether of the simple or the complex. 

~F

Comment Bubble Tip

You are very welcome ~ f, you

You are very welcome ~ f, you always bring out the best in me! mx