where the writers are

June Casagrande Author of "Mortal Syntax" and "Grammar Snobs Are Great Big Meanies"

Funniest Query in History (or at least in the top million). Thanks to Alan for the inspiration!

September 2, 2008, 11:01 am

Okay, it's not a whole query, but here are the first three sentences of the query letter that eventually sold "Grammar Snobs Are Great Big Meanies." (Thanks to Alan for the inspiration!) 

Ms. Agent:

Who among us has not, while composing a “Dear John” letter, fretted over whether to hyphenate “chronic halitosis”? What red-blooded American guy hasn’t found himself at a frat party misusing the word “whom” in a vain attempt to score with a hot English major? Who can honestly say she has not, while composing a sonnet, wondered whether to put a comma between “here I sit” and “broken hearted”?

Rosy Cole

Rosy Cole says:

Bon Mot (or something of the kind!)

Ah, those little clips that bracket off one clause from another and subtly alter meaning. As the philosopher said: "You're not what you think you are, but what you think, you are."

June Casagrande

June Casagrande says:

Actually ...

.. the sentence structures here were just to make sure the punch lines came at the end (a comedy requirement). So I can't take credit for any subtleties of meaning. I was just trying to set 'em up, then knock 'em down.

I'm kind of a laugh whore like that. But what the heck -- it sold a book or three.

Your philosopher line is great. I'm going to use it to replace my punctuation lessons of:

Woman: without her, man is nothing

vs.

Woman without her man is nothing

Thanks!

Alan Goldsher

Alan Goldsher says:

No problemo...

Glad to be of inspirational service, June.  This now makes the number of people I've inspired to three.  YAY, ME!!!

Evie Shockley

Evie Shockley says:

i have indeed . . .

. . . wondered, while writing a sonnet, where to put a comma (though in a line that is, I hope, less commonly encountered than the grammar problem!) . . .

: )