First Bad Review
In the Shadow of His Wings
Today I read the first negative review of my work. It struck me as a blow. Like some stranger had passed by and proclaimed my child ugly, unworthy to be born.I suppose I have been spoiled thus far in my journey as an author, as it was the first to wound me so. I found myself questioning everything, even my heart’s cry to proclaim the love of God as I pour all I have into these stories.
As I read the words I wanted to explain, to bend and weave my own magic to change a mind and seduce a heart. But no. That wasn't right.
Instead I soaked in the pain and felt it and breathed it and knew it. Suddenly, in the car to pick up my son from school, I remembered and prayed:
me and knows my deepest heart. I lay this at Your feet.
Later in the day, I received an email from a woman who had recently read one of my books. Her words were like the balm of Gilead:
Dear Jamie,
Since I know you receive so many letters telling you how much Snow Angel was enjoyed, I find myself at a loss to know how to express myself differently and sincerely to a person who is a natural at expressing emotion...... But, I'll try....... I have been an avid reader since I could read at about age 4, so you can imagine that if I had kept a list of read books, it would be very long. I tried it once, but in 7th grade when my notebook held a list of 200 books for the school year, I discontinued the practice. Having said that, my interests cover a wide range. But this book, this Noah and Elizabeth,..and Jane.....your ability to express emotion and stay pure without becoming bogged down in just words......is wonderful. I must say that at 65, being a romantic at heart, I have read a lot of quality romances.....but this one was not only beautiful, but exciting, informative (Alaska, goldrush)and full of suspense. I could hardly put it down! All that with a lovely Christian ribbon running through it. I read with a 10x magnifier, and have had to do that for a lot of years now..and have been in the talking book program for about 30 years.but readers read,...and in your case, writers write! Thank you so very much for writing Snow Angel. (Would you consider a sequel to Noah & Elizabeth's life in Alaska? I can just imagine Jane and Ben resettling there, close to the Wesleys..........)
How eloquent, how dear to my heart, how timely her email was. It was, to me, a gift from God and a message that renewed my strength. I know I will never please everyone, but the woman in me wants to. Her words, coming from a woman who has read so much, probably seen so much, and like me, is a true romantic at heart, meant more to me than she could ever know.
All For His glory and hiding in the shadow of His wings . . . as I am nothing,
Jamie
- Login Or register To Post Comments
- Send To A Friend





Eric Nichols says:
Dear Jamie
Whenever anyone expresses a negative opinion about me (as astonishing as it may seem, that actually happens occasionally!) I look at it like this. There are six billion people on Earth. You have one opinion. The weight of your opinion is 1 divided by six billion... precisely 1.6666667 to the negative 10th power. YOU work out the math. (I actually told a former boss precisely that to his face...which is probably why he is a FORMER boss...but it sure felt good. Even better, it was the TRUTH!)
Keep looking up!
Eric
Alexander Besher says:
God's review is the only one
God's review is the only one that counts.
Seriously, I understand how you feel, but it's all complete and utter rubbish as you'll discover. The very first EVER book review I got was in Publishers Weekly. The reviewer had a problem with me and suggested out loud that I should never be permitted to write another novel again. (I think such editorializing was a first for a PW review). Next review I got in Publishers Weekly for another novel (by another reviewer) received a starred review with words to the effect that "Besher's pop-cult following should be delighted by this bla bla bla." I didn't take either one seriously. You can have the last review if you want.
P.S. You ARE something and nobody can ever replace you. Reviewers, however, come and go.
Huntington W. Sharp says:
You're Not Alone
Jamie, your fellow Red Room author Victoria Zackheim posted a collection of bad reviews that some of the most revered authors in the English language got early in their careers. Highly recommended reading!
Huntington Sharp, Red Room
Belle Yang says:
Everyone
reading this is experiencing a shudder of recognition. You are most certainly not alone. That awful, Earth-has-dropped-out-from-under-your-feet sensation will pass with a few good nights of sleep. In time, you'll be able to read the review with a sense of detachment.
Shana McLean Moore says:
Timing
Hi Jamie,
I am so glad that the reader comment came to you when it did. On several occasions when I was feeling defeated by the publishing process I considered giving up, but then, like you, along came a message of hope and validation that felt incredibly like a sign that I should persevere.
I truly believe that when we humans are asked to put on the hat of a critic we can find flaws in anything and everything because we feel we are supposed to. Fortunately for us writers, there are many avid readers who aren't looking to see their name in lights for having an ability to write scathing comments about works that are intended to inspire, educate, entertain or offer an escape to those who need a break from their real-life dramas.
It is clear that you have persevered for a very good reason. Thank you for sharing your story so that the rest of us can channel you and that beautiful letter from your reader the next time someone tries to tell us our "baby" is too ugly for the viewing public.
Jamie Carie says:
Smiling Now
What a warm, witty and inviting group of authors you are! Thanks so much for the uplifting words. It is good to know I'm not the only one who has had a thin-skinned day. Thanks too for the link to Victoria Zackheim's post. She's a pretty amazing writer, isn't she?
Hugs to all,
Jamie