X-Men vs. The Red Room
Web Links
It’s all Brian Miller’s fault.
A few weeks ago, Brian, my friend and former law school classmate, emailed me a link to the March 28 edition of Marvel.com.It said that the mutant superheroes, the X-Men, would do battle in the next issue with a mysterious new villain identified only as “Russia’s deadly Red Room.” It looked like a convergence of my past and my present was about to take place. I’ve been an editor at redroom.com for five months. I’d been a huge X-Men fan as a kid, and as a young gay man, I’d been interested in the implicit and explicit subtexts that cultural critics had ascribed to the book. While I hadn’t bought an issue of Uncanny X-Men since early in the Reagan Administration, I knew I’d be going to my comics store in San Francisco’s Haight-Ashbury District to pick up a copy.

I began reading Uncanny X-Men in 1977. My new friend Jeff had pulled me into his world of comic books after introducing himself to me on a school-bus ride home. From the beginning, I liked comics about groups of superheroes—the Justice League, the Avengers, the Fantastic Four—better than titles devoted to heroes working alone like Wonder Woman or Spider-Man. I was attracted to the drama among the members of the teams, of course, as well as the greater array of colorful costumes and super powers; however, what I think I loved best was the camaraderie and teamwork that were always the key to defeating that month’s super villain. Whenever a member of the Fantastic Four, say, became alienated from the team, it gave the villain an opportunity to win; only after the team reunited could the bad guy be defeated. I know I wasn’t the only lonely eight-year-old boy who was encouraged as this moral was repeated again and again.
When I was twelve I left behind both the X-Men and comics in general. I’d occasionally plug into the cultural criticism about the group, fascinated by comparisons that were drawn between how mutants were treated in that fictional universe and how lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people are treated in the real one. These parallels were explicit in the three X-Men films of the early-to-mid-2000s: An anti-mutant politician asks whether parents would want a mutant to teach their children; mutants have to “come out” as such, usually to their parents’ horror, with one mutant’s parent asking if he’d ever tried not being a mutant; and when a “cure” for being a mutant is developed, should it be used? I realized that, even as a boy who wasn’t sure yet how he was different, I’d identified with the X-Men for reasons in addition to their camaraderie.
I read Uncanny X-Men #497 the other night in about five minutes. It’s good to see “my” X-Men again, especially as brought to life by Michael Choi’s illustrations. As usual, the drama comes from the most recent catastrophe to split the team into small groups—the series is even called “Divided We Stand.” Wolverine, Nightcrawler, and Colossus are attacked and kidnapped by what looks like a cabal of shadowy Russian gangsters calling itself The Red Room, while Angel, Cyclops, and Emma Frost are lost in a time warp to San Francisco of the 1960s. (And I bought the comic in the Haight!) Whoever this sinister, mysterious villain turns out to be, it’s a sure bet it will be defeated only when the team stands united, but always outside the mainstream.
Read more Red Room original content.
- Login Or register To Post Comments
- Send To A Friend


Brian Miller says:
X-Men Vs. The Red Room or It's all my fault :)
Your welcome Hunti,
That is a great article/essay you wrote there my friend and I'm not just saying that because I'm mentioned. Though it does help he,he. The X-men may be fighting the Russian Mobster Red Room but they would feel right at home in this Red Room.
James Elliott says:
I never connected with
I never connected with comics or science fiction as a young gay man, I invested my attention toward fine art. Oddly enough, my favorite artists were/are queer--I'm sure my parents would've appreciated me bringing home the occasional Marvel comic instead of retrospectives for Warhol and Mapplethorpe.
Huntington W. Sharp says:
You were more sophisticated...
...than I was, Jhames. I don't know what I would've made of either artist when I was twelve.
Huntington Sharp, Red Room
John Hill says:
Comics were my escape early on
Comics were my escape early on, and I always felt a little less "unusual" after reading some of the outsider-type storylines. Thanks for the great essay reminding me about how I spent a LOT of my time as a kid!
Huntington W. Sharp says:
Thank you...
...for your comment!
Huntington Sharp, Red Room
Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:
I have read a few comic books
Because my boys did. In fact, I have a couple of crates of them in my garage, and I don't quite know what to do with them. But they spent hours and hours with them. For whatever reason, comics provided something. And I can see how you could have realted with the otherness in the X-Men.
I liked the one about the alien suit--it just seemed interesting. But I can't remember the title or the character. Was it Venom?
J
Jessica Barksdale Inclan www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com
Huntington W. Sharp says:
Venom
I believe so, Jessica, but it shows how out of that world I've been when I say I'm not sure either. I think Venom was in one of the Spider-Man movies as well, but I don't know. A little time on Wikipedia would tell us.
I recommend leaving those comics exactly where they are. I wish I had mine from when I was a kid, but they're long gone. I don't know if your boys' books will be worth any money, but they might be someday. At least they might give them a nostalgia shot one day.
Huntington Sharp, Red Room
Steve Hauk says:
Alas,
comic books only bring up bitter memories for me. Kids used to trade like mad _ I assume they still do _ but up the street from us in Crestwood, Missouri was a rich spoiled kid, Jean Paul, who had huge cardboard boxes full of comics, maybe several thousand to our 40 or 50, and Jean Paul loved lording it over us, and hardly ever parted with a thing, even for a day. This was most difficult to take on rainy days, when you couldn't play outside and there was nothing like curling up on a bed or couch, listening to the rain on the roof, and diving into a couple great comics, anything from Huey, Dewey and Louie to a Classics Illustrated Ivanhoe. Hmm, I guess I do have some good memories after all.
Huntington W. Sharp says:
Childhood Memories
Very few are 100% good or bad, right, Steve?
Thanks for commenting!
Huntington Sharp, Red Room
Brian Miller says:
Alien Suit or The symbiote that Loves me
Spiderman was the original wearer of said Alien Suit until he realized it was an alien creature that was slowly changing his perspective and bonding to him. He rejected the suit and thought it was destroyed until Eddie Brock found it and became Venom. Venom came to be one of Spiderman's biggest foes for a while there. The suit was originally found when spidey ripped his traditional super heroic costume while fighting on an Alien world he saw Thor get a new costume from some machines near by and went to the one he thought Thor did instead he released a Symbiotic creature.
Belle Yang says:
Hi, Hunti--I like that moniker ;)
Thank you for the introduction to X-men. I see what I've been missing and will read. If I had come across themt as a teen, I wonder if I would have connected the the mutants. I certainly felt different and X-centric growing up and still feel like a cultural mutant living in the U.S., trying to pass myself a normal.
I've been madly collecting mostly the "highbrow" alternative graphic novels and think "Epileptic" the finest of all in story and art. "It's a Good Life, If You Don't Weaken," is my latest acquisition. This one, you either love it or hate it. I love it.
Huntington W. Sharp says:
Highbrow
Thanks, Belle, but as I commented to Brian, "Hunti" is strictly limited to his use!!! ;)
Seriously, if you're looking for more "highbrow" graphic novels, I can't recommend enough Cairo by your fellow Red Room author G. Willow Wilson. It was one of my best reading experiences of the past year in any genre.
Huntington Sharp, Red Room
Belle Yang says:
I've got "Cairo"
Ordered it as soon as it was featured in Redroom.com. And love all the references to Jalaluddin Rumi and Shams. Willow is super talented and has alternative perspective for all of us. I will follow her career.
Brian Miller says:
High Brow Graphic Novels
Maus would be my choice for the best High Brow Graphic novel. It’s the life of a Holocaust survivor told with anamorphic people. Mice represent the Jews, Cats the Germans, and so on. It very good but very depressing.
Belle Yang says:
Brian, Maus is Great,
but it's been around for quite some time. Pllease check out "Epileptic"! It will astound you with the story and the art.
Thomas Dotson says:
Great article and hmm Maus
First, kudos to Huntington for such a great essay.
Next, how interesting the topic of MAUS came up. I recently purchased Graphic Novels: Everything You Need to Know and have been reading it voraciously. I actually just finished the chapter regarding MAUS and have realized I really need to re-read that series. As a matter of fact, Huntington and I were discussing that very thing in the office a few days ago.
Oh and for the curious I added a few pages from my never finished graphic novel project to my member page for those interested parties.
Huntington W. Sharp says:
Thanks Thomas!
And thanks for my mint copy of #497! :)
Those images you put up are amazing.
Huntington Sharp, Red Room
Belle Yang says:
Oh, goodie and finally, Mr. Dotson!
we get a sneak peak into your graphic novel.
I know Paul Gravett, the author of the book you mention above. He has taken the first 4 pages of my "Forget Sorrow" in Xerox form to display at a college in London..
Thomas Dotson says:
What a small world
Belle, you know absolutely everyone. I'm impressed about your work being on display in London, amazing.
Also, be forgiving of the graphic novel samples I posted. It's very unfinished.
Belle Yang says:
Thomas and Company
http://paulgravett.com/
Paul has his own website. Sign up for his newsletter and you'll be well-informed about the comics world--especially the European creators and festivals :)
Weston Ochse says:
Melancholy
Ahh. Makes me want to pull out my X-Men comics. Such a melancholy zeal to get back those feelings we had when we first turned the page. Thanks for the memory.
Weston Ochse - Dark Fiction Author and Superhero for Rent
Alexander Chee says:
Astonishing X-Men
Huntington, if you haven't seen it yet, check out Joss Whedon's run on the Astonishing X-Men, issues 1-25, collected into several paperbacks or a single hardcover. He nails the team and the story is one of the best since the Dark Phoenix story. Maybe better.
Huntington W. Sharp says:
Whedon's X-Men
As a Buffy fanatic, you bet I read and enjoyed Astonishing X-Men, at least the first couple of series. I haven't been through the whole run, but I did pick up the first hardcover collection. You're right that he gets it just right. Of course, he based Dark Willow on Buffy partly on Dark Phoenix, so it all hangs together.
Huntington Sharp, Red Room